Best Quesadilla Maker in 2021 – All You Need to Know to Buy!

best quesadilla maker

Craving for a quesadilla? Don’t feel like running out and grabbing this yummy, tasty Mexican delight? You should buy a quesadilla maker for your home to fulfill your mid-night food cravings.

To help you out, we have put together comprehensive reviews of the best quesadilla maker that will make it easy for you to make tasty, delightful quesadillas right from the safety of your homes!

Best Quesadilla Maker for 2021 Review: Key Features, Pros, and Cons

Quesadillas are an iconic fast food that is loved by many. However, making them the traditional way takes a lot of time and when you order them online, you are never sure what goes into making them.

Change the game by buying the best quesadilla maker and easily prepare them at home, using safe and healthy ingredients. Here’s the list of the best quesadilla makers in the market, some of which adorn our kitchen countertops as well!

ImageBrandCooking SurfaceWeightColorMaterialPrice
BEST OVERALL
George Foreman10 inch2.5 poundsRedPlastic
PREMIUM PICK
BELLA 8 inch2.9 poundsRedSteel
BEST VALUE
George Foreman9 inch2.8 poundsBlackPlastic
Brentwood 8 inch0.01 poundsRedPlastic
Elite Gourmet 11 inch5 poundsRedAluminum
Hamilton6 inch4.47 poundsRedPlastic
Betty Crocker12 inch0.16 ouncesRedMetal

1. George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker

BEST OVERALL

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Since its debut in 1994, George Foreman has been a well-known name in the world of cooking appliances. After using the brand’s amazing, quesadilla maker, we have no choice but to list it as our overall best pick.

With six deep pockets and a 10-inch cooking diameter, this cheerful machine is very intuitive. Simply sandwich the filling of your choice between two large tortillas and press. Your quesadilla will be ready to eat in less than five minutes!

The deep-dish locking lines ensure that the slices are evenly and properly cut. Since it runs on electricity, the product is apartment-approved. No need to have a backyard or open space to enjoy delicious quesadillas!

Our Observations

Highlighted Features:

  • Power: Electric
  • Tortilla Size: 10 inches
  • Cooking Surface: Non-stick
  • Plates: Fixed

Pros:

  • The entire unit doesn’t take up a lot of space and stands on its side for easy storage.
  • It comes with a nonstick coating, which makes it pretty easy to clean.
  • The deep-dish pockets allow you to cram as much of your favorite filling as you want.
  • The press and seal edges ensure that the cheese doesn’t overflow.

Cons:

  • This product doesn’t come with an off button.
  • The lid becomes very hot, so you have to handle it with care.

2. BELLA (13506) 8-inch Quesadilla Maker

PREMIUM PICK

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Making healthy meals for yourself and your family shouldn’t be an energy-draining chore. The BELLA Quesadilla ensures this by keeping the process of quesadilla-making very simple. This amazing 8-inch quesadilla maker promises to have hot, cheesy quesadillas on your plate in less than 5 minutes.

There are six segments of the non-stick plate which allows you to separate the slices very easily. What we really like about this model is that it comes with a drip reservoir which helps to reduce the mess while making quesadillas.

Moreover, the product comes with a recipe book so that even if you are not good at cooking, simply follow the recipes and you will be good to go!

Our Observations

Highlighted Features:

  • Power: Electric
  • Tortilla Size: 8 inches
  • Cooking Surface: Non-stick
  • Plates: Fixed

Pros:

  • The non-stick coating allows you to clean the product very easily.
  • Its built-in reservoir minimizes the mess while making this cheesy dish.
  • The power light on the top lets you know the cooking status of your quesadillas.
  • It doesn’t take up a lot of space and you can store it upright.
  • The plates warm up very quickly and you can prepare crisp, warm quesadillas in no time.

Cons:

  • There is no on/off switch.
  • It has shallow pockets, so you can’t add a lot of filling to your quesadillas.

3. George Foreman Indoor Grill and Panini Press

BEST VALUE

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Searching for a quesadilla maker that is easy on the pocket and doesn’t take up a lot of space as well? You should take a look at this George Foreman Panini Press. This multi-purpose machine can press paninis, grill chicken, and sear steaks to perfection along with making perfect, juicy quesadillas.

This updated model comes in a compact size and is perfect if you are cooking for two. Simply fill the tortilla and press the top to cook it quickly and perfectly without having to flip it. Since the product has a sloped grill, any excess oil will be drained into the removable drip tray that comes with it.

The drip tray is dishwasher safe so you don’t have to worry about cleaning it as well. The non-stick coating is easy to clean and durable. You can effortlessly store it on its side, saving precious counter space.

Our Observations

Highlighted Features:

  • Power: Electric
  • Tortilla Size: 9 inches
  • Cooking Surface: Non-stick
  • Plates: Fixed

Pros:

  • This product is great for small spaces.
  • The sloped grilling surface ensures that you enjoy leaner, fat-free meals.
  • It is a multi-purpose appliance and you can use it to make many things other than quesadillas.
  • The floating hinge on this model is perfect for thicker quesadillas.

Cons:

  • Some users complain about the durability of the non-stick coating.

4. Brentwood Quesadilla Maker – Best Lightweight Quesadilla Maker

Read Customer Reviews Here »

If you are searching for a lightweight, compact quesadilla maker, then you should look no further than the Brentwood Quesadilla Maker. It is a very user-friendly model with a bright and bold design.

The 8-inch non-stick plate is divided into six sections and you can make crispy quesadillas in record time. With a removable drip tray, you can rest assured that you will not create a mess while cooking.

The compact and lightweight style of this quesadilla maker makes it perfect for couples or for people who are living on their own. The product weighs only 0.01 pounds which is an amazing feat in itself.

Our Observations

Highlighted Features:

  • Power: Electric
  • Tortilla Size: 9 inches
  • Cooking Surface: Non-stick
  • Plates: Fixed

Pros:

  • It is very easy and simple to use.
  • The non-stick surface makes the quesadilla maker very easy to clean.
  • It cuts the quesadilla into six perfectly sized portions.
  • The indicator light on the top lets you know when your quesadillas are done.
  • Its removable drip tray is a nice feature.

Cons:

  • The latch tends to break very easily.

5. Elite Gourmet Quesadilla Maker – Best Crispy Quesadilla Maker

Read Customer Reviews Here »

In the reviews above, we have seen that some quesadilla makers feature a removable drip tray. However, the Elite Gourmet Quesadilla Maker takes this one step ahead by featuring a drainage rim along with a drip tray.

This makes cleaning the quesadilla maker very easy. This 11-inch quesadilla maker divides the food into six even pieces with the help of built-in scoring guides. It is very easy to use, and all you have to do is place the filled tortillas in the maker and you will be good to go.

The interior of this product is non-stick, which makes it very easy to clean. There are two indicator lights – one for power and one for readiness. The first one will light up while the product is pre-heating and when it is ready to cook, the second one will light up.

Our Observations

Highlighted Features:

  • Power: Electric
  • Tortilla Size: 11 inches
  • Cooking Surface: Non-stick

Pros:

  • You can store it vertically after using it for easy storage.
  • The drainage rim and drip tray catch the melting grease, allowing you to have healthy, lean meals.
  • The quesadilla maker heats up very quickly and you can have food on your plate within minutes.
  • If you like your quesadillas thin and crispy, the shallow pockets of this machine will help you make the quesadilla of your dreams.

Cons:

  • You can’t make thick quesadillas with a lot of filling with this quesadilla maker.
  • The plastic top is fragile and is prone to breaking.

6. Hamilton Beach 25409 Quesadilla Maker – Best Restaurant Quality Quesadilla Maker

Read Customer Reviews Here »

Want to have restaurant-quality quesadilla at your home in 5 mins? Take a look at the Hamilton Beach Quesadilla Maker. This product has a unique pre-head system that makes sure your quesadillas come out ready to eat within the stipulated time frame.

Moreover, the product has handle grips that make it very easy for you to carry it around the kitchen if need be. Since we love making quesadillas on vacation, we used to take this along as well.

When it comes to wallet-friendly kitchen appliances, Hamilton Beach does a great job. It is designed to accommodate 6 to 8-inch tortillas and is perfect for making appetizers. The nonstick surface heats evenly and ensures your quesadillas are perfectly cooked.

Our Observations

Highlighted Features:

  • Power: Electric
  • Tortilla Size: 6 inches
  • Cooking Surface: Non-stick

Pros:

  • Since it comes with leak-proof rings, you don’t have to worry about creating a mess on the kitchen top.
  • The preheat feature makes sure your food gets cooked quickly.
  • The non-stick layers and the leakproof seal keeps your cooking experience clean.
  • You get four tasty quesadilla recipes with this product as well.
  • The pre-heat lights let you know when the machine is ready for use.

Cons:

  • The cooking plate is relatively small in size.

7. Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Quesadilla Maker – Best Multi-Purpose Quesadilla Maker

Read Customer Reviews Here »

The last but certainly not the least product on our list is the Betty Crocker Quesadilla Maker which is the holy grail of flatbread cooking if you ask us. Stuff your tortilla with the filling of your choice and enjoy a delicious, exotic quesadilla within minutes.

What’s more, you can cook omelets, nachos, pizzas, and quite a lot more in this high-powered machine. With a non-stick interior, you can easily clean it up in one wipe. The automatic thermostat makes sure that the internal temperature remains constant so that your food is cooked thoroughly and evenly.

Our Observations

Highlighted Features:

  • Power: Electric
  • Tortilla Size: 12 inches
  • Cooking Surface: Non-stick
  • Plates: Fixed

Pros:

  • If you are searching for a multi-purpose kitchen appliance instead of a dedicated quesadilla maker, this will be a good option for you.
  • The self-regulating thermostat keeps both the grill and the food safe.
  • The 12-inch large plate makes sure you can fulfill your hunger cravings with large quesadillas.
  • The non-stick lining and the sealing rims help in keeping things clean as you cook.

Cons:

  • There are no ridges so you will have to cut the quesadillas yourself.

best quesadilla maker

Buying Guide

What’s better than having a perfectly made quesadilla maker right from the comfort of your home, right. However, with so many options available in the market, how do you choose the best one?

You need to keep an eye on things such as size, material, price, etc. Let’s take a brief look at them.

Size

The first thing that you need to look at is the size of the quesadilla maker. Most quesadilla makers come in 8-inch or 10-inch models. There are larger models as well, and you can choose the one that fits the needs of you and your family.

Check the tortilla size you usually use and then select the size of the quesadilla maker accordingly. Moreover, you like your quesadillas to be sealed, select a quesadilla maker that presses and seals the edges.

The Betty Crocker BC-2958CR Quesadilla Maker is the largest quesadilla maker while Hamilton Beach 25409 Quesadilla Maker is the smallest one on our list.  If you have a healthy appetite, you should go for larger sizes and in case you want kid-friendly portion sizes, go for the smaller-sized quesadilla makers.

Material

The most important part in terms of the materials is the lid of the quesadilla machine. Plastic lids are usually prone to cracking, so you have to use them very carefully. Meta lids are more durable and can withstand harsh usage and pressure.

The only issue with metal quesadilla makers is that they get very hot while you are using them so you have to keep this in mind while using them. When it comes to the electric-powered quesadilla makers, they usually come with nonstick coatings.

Nonstick coatings are not impervious to damage, so you should be very careful while using the machines and not use any abrasive scrubbers or sharp utensils.

Depth

The depth of the quesadilla maker is also a factor you need to consider. If you like a crispy quesadilla with minimal filling, then you should go with a shallow-depth quesadilla maker such as BELLA (13506) 8-inch Quesadilla Maker.

If you love to have lots of filling, then you should go with a quesadilla maker that has deep-dish pockets such as George Foreman Electric Quesadilla Maker.

Price

While buying a quesadilla maker, you have to keep an eye on the bank as well. Generally, you can find an affordable machine if you know what to look for. The George Foreman Quesadilla Maker is the most affordable option on our list.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: How to use a quesadilla maker?

It is very easy to use a quesadilla maker. Simply use the stack method. You should lay one tortilla on the cooking surface and add the filling of your choice. Now, place the second tortilla on top of it.

Close the lid of the quesadilla maker and the machine will cook the quesadilla for you in no time. Some quesadilla makers utilize the fold method as well, where you have to fold the tortilla before cooking it.

Q: How can you clean a quesadilla maker?

Most of the quesadilla makers feature a non-stick surface which makes them very easy to clean. Simply wait till the machine is cool and then use a clean towel to wipe off any debris on the machine.

If the machine has removable plates, you can take them out and gently scrub them with soap and water. We recommend that you wash the plates by hand even if they are dishwasher safe to preserve the nonstick coating.

Q: Can I make something else with a quesadilla maker?

Yes, you can use a quesadilla maker to cook various things such as french toast, pancakes, omelets, etc. Moreover, the multipurpose Betty Crocker Quesadilla maker in our list allows you to cook pizzas in it as well!

Conclusion

With the help of the best quesadilla maker, you can have as many restaurant-quality, cheesy treats while sitting on your sofa, watching your favorite movie. Go through our reviews of the best rated quesadilla maker in 2021 and enjoy the Mexican delight!

Happy Eating, Folks!

homestuffpro.com is reader-supported and a part of the Amazon Affiliates Program. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Read our disclosure for more information.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments